Menu of Another Broken Egg Cafe in Wetherington, Ohio, USA

Menu Overview

Another Broken Egg Cafe, nestled in West Chester Township, Ohio, offers a brunch experience that skillfully balances traditional Southern comfort with creative flair. This café’s menu is a compelling blend of hearty classics and inventive dishes, perfect for those seeking both familiar comfort and new brunch adventures.

The Cinnamon Roll French Toast stands out as a decadent highlight—its sweet, gooey layers perfectly complement the café’s commitment to comfort food elevated with finesse. Equally impressive is the Shrimp 'N Grits, hailed by regulars as arguably the best around. With Gulf shrimp nestled over creamy city grits, this dish carries authentic Louisiana flavors wrapped in a velouté sauce that speaks to genuine Southern culinary roots. This is where the café’s spirit truly shines, delivering deep, satisfying flavors that linger long after the meal ends.

Egg lovers will find delight in options like the Eggs Blackstone Benedict with Grits and the Hash Brown Benedict. These dishes marry traditional eggs benedict with rich, regional twists such as savory blackstone sauce and crispy hash browns, showcasing the kitchen's ability to innovate while respecting classic brunch foundations.

The menu’s "Sensible Creations," including the Shrimp Benedict and the Monterey Power Omelette, offer lighter, yet flavorful choices. The egg-white omelet packed with chicken, green chilies, and topped with fresh avocado provides a nutrient-rich, indulgent option without excess. This balance is especially appreciated in a brunch setting known for heavier fare.

For those with a sweet tooth or craving a playful twist, the Cookie Dough Waffle and Pumpkin Waffle provide memorable, indulgent treats, while the Fruit Bowl offers a refreshing palate cleanser. The 1/2 Order of Biscuit Beignets adds a delightful Southern touch with airy, fried goodness, perfect with the café’s own Bloody Mary Mix—a cocktail mix that elevates the brunch beverage experience.

The traditional classics such as the Biscuit & Gravy with house-made sausage patties and eggs any style, or the Huevos Rancheros featuring crispy tortillas and spicy black beans, deliver generous portions and bold flavors. This respect for hearty, down-home cooking ensures a satisfying meal that appeals to all appetites.

Customer feedback reflects a consistent appreciation for fresh ingredients, attentive service, and a warm, lively atmosphere, though some note the ambient noise levels during peak times. The attentive staff, as noted by many guests, enhances the dining experience, making the visit feel personalized and welcoming.

In sum, Another Broken Egg Cafe offers a robust, thoughtful brunch menu that caters to diverse tastes—from indulgent comfort food to health-conscious selections. It is a place where Southern charm meets creative brunch innovation, ensuring each visit leaves a memorable impression. Whether it’s the bold flavors of the Shrimp 'N Grits or the sweetness of the Cinnamon Roll French Toast, this café delivers with authenticity and heart.